It’s Time for a Poll!

You can vote for two shows.  Two shows only.  Otherwise, things could be messy.  Of course, that’s assuming anyone (besides Natalie) will vote.  😉

C’mon followers, all it takes is one or two ticks.  Don’t be shy!

(Sleepy Hollow isn’t included because it’s already been renewed for a second season.)


Let the rating mania begin!

Now that Supernatural March Madness is over, it’s time to get back to reviewing and rating the shows.  And there’s an exciting new twist —> YOU get to rate the episodes!

We could use stars to rate the episodes, as I’ve done in the past.  Or we could make the experience more personal with other icons.  Here are our options:

So let’s decide.

Supernatural March Madness Finale

We have a winner!

Congratulations to  “What Is and What Should Never Be,”  this year’s Supernatural March Madness Champion.

Dean and Sam enjoy a cold beer after an exciting tournament.

What’s better than a cold beer after an exciting tournament?

[Sadly, I don’t have a screencap from “What Is and What Should Never Be” that  includes both Sam and Dean.]

Thanks, everyone!


Supernatural March Madness Championship!

The Championship Game!

We’ve spent the last month deciding which episodes deserve to earn the title of Champion.  And now we’re here!

Dean and Sam anxiously await the outcome of the Championship game.

Dean and Sam: thunderstruck and awed that we’ve finally reached the Championship game.

Let’s do this!


Supernatural March Madness: Final 4

The Final Four!

For the first time ever, Supernatural March Madness will play out nearly in sync with the NCAA tournament.  The Final Four will run this weekend, with the Championship game being published on Monday, April 8.

Dean awaits Sam's approval of his awesome hamburger.

Dean and Sam plan to celebrate the Supernatural March Madness Final Four with  awesome hamburgers.

I know some folks are in mourning the loss of “Lazarus Rising” to “Mystery Spot.”  To quote former President Bill Clinton, I feel your pain.

But the tournament must go on!

Continue reading


Supernatural March Madness: Elite 8

The Elite Eight

It’s time for the Elite Eight, otherwise known as your favorite episode from each year.  (Well, excluding “In My Time of Dying,” which retired undefeated.)

Sam dresses as an FBI agent, Dean dresses as a mideival dude.

Sometimes we dress up. Sometimes we dress even more up.

Who will make it to the Final Four?  You decide!

Continue reading


Supernatural March Madness: Sweet 16, part 2

The Sweet Sixteen!  Again!

Let’s continue with the Sweet Sixteen, the best episodes from seasons 5-8.

Sam and Dean spend another night in a motel room.

Another day, another motel room. Yep, must be Supernatural.

Charge forth and vote!

Continue reading